The Metaphysics of the Evil Eye

8 02 2010

Part I – Things gettin’ worse all the time

My family is Mexican, ergo, I am a fatalist. Americans can’t perceive what that really means. In a way, I am just as American as anyone else living in the U.S. of A., but my family definitely isn’t. It’s hard for someone with so much Latin blood and upbringing to say: “Hey kiddo, keep your chin up. Things will get better.” If I do say that, what I really mean is, “Yeah, life sucks. But don’t worry, you’ll get used to it.” Or as my ex-abbot (a Greek) was prone to saying (perhaps quoting someone else?): “Whatever happens, it’ll be bad”.

Perhaps this was the social ground of the phemonemon of the “evil eye” in such cultures. The evil eye always has to do with envy. In Mexico and other parts of Latin America, the evil eye is cast inadvertenly on small children by people who admire them too much. Growing up, my mother was always taught to touch a child who she had admired, lest she give the child a preternatural illness that could possibly cause death. Having a beautiful, healthy child was seen as being a dangerous thing; people would “desire” the child, and that desire, even from afar, could be fatal.

In my rather unsystematic studies of folk belief, I have found that, not without accident perhaps, southern Italian ideas of the evil eye parellel the Mexican manifestations of the phenomenon. Indeed, the best description given for the basis of the evil eye (malocchio, for the multilingual), can be found in the book, Italian American Folklore by Frances Malpezzani and William M. Clements. They write:

Connected with the deeply rooted fatalism of the southern Italian peasant world view, malocchio reflects a pessimism that perceives potential threats from almost anyone and assumes that good fortune cannot endure. To prosper, according to this world view, is to invite envy. And envy generates ill feelings that may result in harm befalling its target. Malocchio makes concrete the abstract envy that pervades a universe defined by only a limited amount of good.

“A limited amount of good.” Americans would best chew on that phrase. For if there was anything so “unAmerican”, so counterintuitive to how we work, learn, and perceive the world, it is the idea of a “limited amount of good”. We are taught that the good is something we create out of thin air. It is a manner of cutting the pie into an infinite amount of pieces until everyone has a share. Indeed, in the metaphysical sense, modernity is the overcoming of fatalism; it is the overcoming of caste and “station in life” so that we can reach our “full potential”. God is on our side since He has thrown open the floodgates of infinite goodness. We are more informed, more comfortable, and of course, better people than our ancestors. Even in our nostalgia for the past, there is a sense of living in a superior age, and our pining for it is just as rational as a four year old’s pining for Disneyworld.

Of course, I wouldn’t want to go back to the life of a Mexican campesino or an Italian paesano either, but their approach to life should at least give us pause. Especially in the fields of religion and culture, we may want to have our cake and eat it too, but perhaps our ancestors knew better than that. Perhaps our universe is governed by the principle of a “limited good”, and it is just a matter of time before the payback comes, either on the microcosmic or macrocosmic level.



4 responses

10 02 2010

I had always though the evil eye was broader than that (affecting children already born). The cause being envy, causes its victim misfortune in the ability to generate the objects of envy…generating property and children.

Barrenness was once a curse. Nowadays it’s almost a virtue…until boomer or post-boomer wants their little designer child…then watch out. Before the social state, children were money in the bank. A person’s fertility was wealth…not only their personal fertility, but the fertility of their fields, orchards, and livestock.

With the social state, children aren’t necessary…or so it’s thought…after all, who will contribute to it when we draw from it? Who also lives so close to the land anymore, except for rural ‘peasants’? More people’s fertility…or lack thereof…is tied up in their home equity or 401K.

Perhaps there is a limited amount of good in the here and now. I don’t have that answer, but it does seem that the evil eye can be cast upon whole nations not merely individuals.

9 02 2010

Rest assured that this mentality – the belief in mau olhado/olho gordo – is still alive and well in Portuguese rural areas (and urban ones as well, though not so overt). I’ve noticed that it is especially linked with children. Perhaps that would explain why many Portuguese still don’t like it when people smile at their children.

8 02 2010
Dr. S. Petersen

To say “a limited amount of good” is to say, “earthly life”. I find less contradiction (than I percieve you do) between your old-worldy people, your campensinos, and sound Catholic doctrine. God is infinite and He (alone) is good. But here we have tribulation. In a manner of speaking, the less we care for or seek earthly good, the more joy we have. The fear for a beautiful child is well founded–without grace, the gifts of nature and fortune are snares.
Also, I think I was harsh in my remarks yesterday. I happened to read in Sam. Johnson about the ruins of the (Roman Catholic) churches and monasteries in the Scottish Highlands and Orkneys. Johnson observed that in getting rid of “popish superstition” they also lost popish piety. I think, perhaps, part of what you were saying (but I doubt I’ll ever see good in Voodoo) is that it is easy for the comfortable Westerner to overlook the value of the belief and moral conduct that stem from irrational and idiosyncratic religious practices.

8 02 2010
Arturo Vasquez

WHO DAT!!!!!!!

Now that that is out of the way, we can move on…

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: