In praise of mediocrity

30 09 2008

We are not supposed to praise mediocrity. Modernity despises it, though it is its best purveyor. Nor are we supposed to be able to live with hypocrisy. These are things that in the Gospel and New Testament are explicitly condemned and despised. So any praise of hypocrisy and mediocrity would be borderline sacreligious in the eyes of some.

If we are in the moral and social mess that we are in now, it is because we have declared an all-out war on mediocrity. This began of course with the Reformation, which was followed by the Counter-Reformation, the Enlightenment, and the list could go from there. The society that we had found ourselves living in was never good enough. There was always something that needed to be changed, overturned, cleaned up, and improved. We expect improvement, we crave it. We are always avaricious when it comes to things getting better: spiritually, financially, socially, and personally. Christians are tolerant; we are supposed to love all people. Anti-Christians one up the Christians by being even more tolerant; towards homosexuals, women who want abortions, people who divorce, etc. And to add insult to injury, Christians can’t even follow the rules that make them so intolerant in the first place, and anyone with any cursory knowledge of the world knows it.

So the pursuit of perfection, the constant drive to “make things better” becomes the demise of institutions, the iconoclasm against the forms of the past, and the foundation of the eternal dictatorship of the present. Worship must be improved; the old prayers are too long, too complicated, too repetitive, and not rich enough with meaning. Old codes of theological formulation and moral behavior are not thorough enough, are too constricting, and fail to convince man, ever skeptical man, of why he should believe in the specters of the past and fear them.  Truth must spring from “in here”, in the warm bosom of good feeling, in the always certain knowledge that things are getting better all the time. All messes need to be cleaned up, all prejudices cast out. And if this is not possible, than why bother with any of it? Either life must be sanitized, predictable, and perfectly ordered, or it must not exist.

That is why I praise mediocrity. The rote catechisms and the old beaten-up novena pamphlets were created for mediocre people, people who were addicted to routine, who took the way of life for granted. Old moral codes had hypocrisy built into them; it may have not been possible to buy off God with good works, but that didn’t mean that you weren’t supposed to try. Instead of running the mad sprint of perfection, it preferred to run the labyrinthine marathon of rules, infractions, and very gradual, if non-existent, improvement. Things are not getting better all the time. They pretty much stay the same. You are not learning to behave yourself more and more, but only learning to better live with and cover up your imperfections. You are not growing in your spiritual and emotional life; you are always where you started, and any progress is purely illusory. But like a stone at the bottom of the stream, we imperceptibly are smoothed out by the flow of time. Simply try not to notice it, and perhaps, one day, you will be better.



2 responses

1 10 2008

Now that’s refreshing!

1 10 2008
Josh S

This began of course with the Reformation, which

Objection! It “began,” at the very least, with the monastic reform movements. But reform and renewal movements don’t really have a beginning at all.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: